Becoming Noble

Becoming Noble

Home
Podcast
Archive
About

Dissident leaders must have children

In our anti-family society, it's a necessary worthiness test

Johann Kurtz's avatar
Johann Kurtz
Jun 15, 2024
∙ Paid
Cross-posted by Becoming Noble
"Johann Kurtz is quickly proving to be a calm, concise voice of reason in a world of knee-jerk reactions and vile perspectives. I've wondered about this myself, and have had to 'deal' with leadership who wanted to encroach upon my family, ABOUT my children, and they had no clue about reality...only that they supposed to have authority over me to do so. No. This is a good start to many more cross-promotions I'd like to have, forwarding such thinkers as Johann to families around the world. Enjoy."
- Jaime Buckley 💎

A few days ago I posted a note which proved controversial:

The cadre of childless thinkers who provide increasingly convoluted hot takes on solving the fertility & intelligence crisis without having kids themselves is emblematic of the failure of the online right. Literally just a basic human, real world step and they can’t take it.

I’m sure they’ll argue that it’s impossible to find a good partner etc. etc. Sorry: if you can’t do that basic life step, you have no business influencing or leading others

I chose my words carefully, and I stand by the statement. Nevertheless, some have ignored the words I actually wrote, and have taken the opportunity to denounce me as ignorant, unfeeling, and superior. Now people are writing whole articles to this effect, I should respond.

Here are some things I did not say:

  1. Childless people are not entitled to an opinion;

  2. Childless people are incapable of great insights;

  3. Childless people do not have the right to complain;

  4. Finding a mate is easy;

  5. Having children is easy.

None of these are true.

Instead, my criticism applies - as stated - to the following group: ‘childless thinkers who provide increasingly convoluted hot takes on solving the fertility & intelligence crisis’.


Subscribe to Becoming Noble to continue reading

Visit the author’s Substack to subscribe and read more.

No posts

© 2026 Johann Kurtz · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture