27 Comments
User's avatar
Gelicost's avatar

Really enjoyed this one and looking forward to the rest of the series! HP, perhaps understandably, catches a lot of flak from both sides of the political aisle. It's refreshing to see a more charitable treatment.

Expand full comment
Johann Kurtz's avatar

Thanks Gelicost!

Expand full comment
Diamond Boy's avatar

It’s a shame that the social sciences are destroying our culture through immigration.

Expand full comment
Johann Kurtz's avatar

Yeah, that's why I labelled it the 'last' British myth: I don't think any of the themes in this series are going to mean a huge amount to immigrants who are not from North West Europe.

Expand full comment
Diamond Boy's avatar

I don’t have anything against the newcomers, but when you inundate a country with different people, you destroy what you had and they’ve done it on purpose. They hate us.

I am Canadian. It’s not nearly as tragic in Canada because we were a new country. The vast numbers of new Canadians, from everywhere, is making Toronto a very interesting city. But the destruction of Great Britain is unconscionable. It is a crime. It is treason.

Expand full comment
Johann Kurtz's avatar

It's a crying shame in Canada too! Canadian culture might have been younger but it is/was no less real. I have good friends there.

Expand full comment
Diamond Boy's avatar

Yup, but it’s gone, that Canada. (Quebec nationalism is on the rise inter-provincial immigration threats to swap out the Québécois and they are hopping mad.)

Canada is in big trouble.

The loss of Albion is evil. Left liberal progressive thought is evil: fascism, communism, and the remaining ism, liberalism are evil.

Expand full comment
Dudley Newright's avatar

In ancient times,

Hundreds of years before the dawn of history

Lived a strange race of people, the Druids

No one knows who they were or what they were doing

But their legacy remains

Hewn into the living rock, of Stonehenge

https://i.makeagif.com/media/9-11-2017/Pj-sOM.mp4

Expand full comment
James Mathison's avatar

"...the Anglo-Saxon ideal of treowþ: a precursor to our word truth which articulates not ‘factualty’ but faith and loyalty. The word of the man of treowþ is his bond..." (15:20)

By thinking about this word "treowþ", and your explanation of it, I gained a glimpse into the mindset of the men of the spring of our civilisation. For them, "factuality" must have been obvious. The Sun rises, the rain falls, a child is born... facts hardly required a word as they simply are what is. What was sometimes hidden and always meaningful would be a man's character, whether or not he was "true".

In our current season, when materialist "reason" reigns, a religion appropriate for the times arises, science, which has its own mysteries - the "facts". e.g. We are made of cells that contain mitochondria which produce ATP to energise our metabolism. All religions require revelations of what was once hidden in order to fulfil that role.

The key difference is that the occult knowledge of our white-robed priests is ever-changing as new scriptures (studies) are written to update old "facts". And regardless, what they offer has little bearing on our lives other than to strip them of meaning and offer us relief from the moral burden of treowþ. Very interesting.

Expand full comment
Ryan Kreager's avatar

Ryan’s Wife here! 👋

You have laid out a thought that I’ve been noodling on for some time:

“In her universe, if one looks closely, magic always respects a certain form: it is incantational and not invocational. That is to say: words are spoken, and events happen - but words are not used to summon demonic forces or spirits which do the bidding of the sorcerer. Hers is a form of magic made apprehensible to the Christian mind.”

Thank you for expressing this distinction!

It feels like the fully formed thought I’ve been trying to figure out for some time. Why is it that I don’t mind the magic of Rowling’s world, but I have extreme caution about anything “spells & incantations” in the real world? Because there is an ontological difference between the incantational magic within her mythological world and the invocational magic of this real world.

Expand full comment
Johann Kurtz's avatar

Yes! She's a practicing Christian and has made it clear that she doesn't believe in magic. I think - strange as this is to say - that this shines through in the work

Expand full comment
Selma Schuller's avatar

Beautiful and fascinating piece, Thankyou. As an Australian, our cultural heritage is evolved from mother England, yet uniquely shaped and moulded by the tyranny of distance and so many other influences.

Expand full comment
Johann Kurtz's avatar

Thank you Selma. Nice to know I have Australian readers

Expand full comment
Andrew Flattery's avatar

Rule, Brittania!

Expand full comment
Johann Kurtz's avatar

May she rise again

Expand full comment
Edwin Leap's avatar

Wonderful essay! As an American, but long in love with our shared cultural heritage, this is very meaningful to me. I read the Bible to my children, and many other works, but Beowulf was among the things we shared. It was probably inevitable given that I bear the name Edwin. Thank you!

Expand full comment
Johann Kurtz's avatar

Thank you Edwin!

Expand full comment
S. T. Karnick's avatar

Your description of Rowling’s imaginary England is fascinating and accurate: a world resacralized. Another fiction series that reflects that approach is Randall Garrett’s Lord Darcy stories (https://www.goodreads.com/series/43050-lord-darcy). Garrett explicitly imagines a post-medieval world in which machines did not replace magic. As in the Potter books, magic is subject to clear rules and involves incantation and not invocation.

Expand full comment
Johann Kurtz's avatar

Oh very interesting. Thanks for the link

Expand full comment
S. T. Karnick's avatar

You're welcome. I hope that you'll enjoy the stories and find them as interesting as I have.

Expand full comment
Marek's avatar

Thank you for writing this wonderful exploration. It is the mystery of the ancient druids that makes the subject so intriguing to me. Where did they come from, where did they go? And what is it that they left behind for us? And really, I don't even need the answers to these questions. The inquiry, the thoughts themselves are enough. Your piece made me think of C.S.Lewis' "This Hideous Strength."

Expand full comment
Johann Kurtz's avatar

Thanks Marek.

Expand full comment
Thomas Ambrose's avatar

Great post! I especially love the reference to treowþ. Our modern notion is not so different, if seen suitably; but it is somewhat impoverished. I have a whole essay rattling around in me about truth as troth and loyalty. I look forward to the next part with interest, and I shall have to watch that commentary on Sir Gawain to tide me over in the mean time.

Expand full comment
Johann Kurtz's avatar

Dr. Masson is great.

Expand full comment
Betsy's avatar

I truly loved this. Thank you so much much.

Expand full comment
Johann Kurtz's avatar

Thanks Betsy!

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment removed
Dec 2
Comment removed
Expand full comment
Johann Kurtz's avatar

Thank you Curtis

Expand full comment